Atiku asks INEC to open AI system for independent audit ahead of 2027 elections

According to the ADC Presidential candidate, AI should serve only as an administrative tool under human supervision and must not have the authority to delete, alter or permanently block election results.

The presidential candidate of the African Democratic Congress (ADC), Atiku Abubakar, has asked the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to disclose the artificial intelligence (AI) system it plans to deploy in processing polling unit results ahead of the 2027 general elections, demanding that the technology be subjected to independent scrutiny.

Atiku, a former vice president of Nigeria, said the commission must make its technical framework, operational procedures and decision-making processes public to assure Nigerians that the technology would not interfere with the transmission of election results.

He also called for independent cybersecurity experts, political party representatives and civil society technologists to be granted access to the system’s source code, training data and decision logs for an audit before INEC’s nationwide mock accreditation scheduled for 28 November.

A statement on Thursday by his Director of Strategic Communication, Phrank Shaibu, said Atiku made the demands in a petition dated 17 November and addressed to INEC Chairman Joash Amupitan on behalf of the ADC, allied opposition parties, civil society organisations, technology monitors and pro-democracy stakeholders.

The petition, titled Demand for Algorithmic Transparency, Independent Audit, and Accountability in INEC’s Deployment of Artificial Intelligence for the 2027 General Elections, formally asked the commission to ensure transparency and accountability in its proposed integration of AI and intelligent document-processing systems into Nigeria’s electoral infrastructure.

The document shows that INEC acknowledged receipt of the petition on 18 November. Copies also bear acknowledgement stamps from the ECOWAS Commission, among other receiving institutions.

Atiku’s demands follow INEC’s announcement that it would integrate AI and intelligent document processing into the process linking its Data Verification and Authentication System (DIVAS) with the INEC Result Viewing Portal (IReV).

The petition identifies the proposed technology as a system designed to mediate the transmission of results between DIVAS and IReV.

It argues that the introduction of technology into the electoral process must be accompanied by independent oversight, warning that an unchecked system could undermine public confidence in elections.

In the petition, Atiku recalled the introduction of the Smart Card Reader, the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS) and the IReV portal, arguing that although technology was introduced to address electoral malpractice, its deployment without adequate safeguards could create new vulnerabilities.

“From the introduction of the Smart Card Reader to the deployment of the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS) and the IReV portal, the promise has always been that technology would cure the plague of manual rigging, ballot snatching, and result falsification.

“However, history has shown us that technology in the hands of an unchecked umpire can be weaponised,” it read.

Atiku said Nigerians deserved to understand how the technology would assess election results and the implications of any discrepancies it identifies.

“INEC cannot ask Nigerians to trust a system whose rules they are forbidden to see. If an algorithm can flag a polling unit result sheet, the public deserves to know what triggers that flag, who set the threshold, who can change it and what happens to the result afterward,” he said.

He warned that the system could delay the processing of valid results if it failed to recognise polling unit result sheets because of poor image quality, unfamiliar handwriting or worn-out paper.

He also cautioned against the possibility of inconsistent standards in which similar errors in different locations could attract different treatment, potentially delaying the transmission of results in some polling units.

Demands transparency and human oversight
Atiku asked INEC to publish the sources of the system’s training data, the criteria for flagging discrepancies and the identities of its developers and third-party vendors.

He further demanded that the commission establish clear procedures for handling result sheets flagged by the technology, including identifying the officials responsible for reviewing them, documenting decisions, notifying political parties and providing a mechanism for promptly challenging errors.

According to him, AI should serve only as an administrative tool under human supervision and must not have the authority to delete, alter or permanently block election results.

Atiku also raised concerns about the legal status of the physical polling unit result sheet, Form EC8A, which records the results announced at polling units.

He urged INEC to reaffirm publicly that the completed and signed physical result sheet would retain its legal status and explain how disputes between the document and an AI assessment would be resolved.

“A machine’s verdict cannot be allowed to quietly displace the evidence witnessed by voters and party agents,” he said.

Atiku also called for political parties to have real-time monitoring access to the digital results processing system through a dedicated dashboard or an appropriate observer interface.

He said such access would enable parties to identify unusual patterns of result flagging, delays or blocked uploads while an election was ongoing.

He urged the National Assembly to summon INEC’s leadership and its Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Directorate to explain the system’s design, safeguards and audit arrangements.

Atiku also called on election observers and international partners to monitor the digital handling of election results, beyond developments at polling units.

He advised voters to lawfully document results as announced and displayed at their polling units to provide a public record against which electronically uploaded results could be verified.

Atiku said the credibility of the 2027 elections would depend partly on whether voters could independently establish that results recorded at polling units were accurately reflected in INEC’s digital systems.

“Our Affordable Life campaign is a promise to bring down the crushing cost of living, restore opportunity and make government answer to the people it serves. Nigerians must be free to accept or reject that promise at the ballot box,” he said.

He urged INEC to address the concerns before the election, warning that failure to provide transparency could deepen public mistrust in the electoral process.