Justice Inyang Ekwo, who delivered the judgment on Wednesday, held that Suswam won the majority of valid votes cast during the party’s senatorial primary election and was therefore entitled to the APC ticket.
The judge ruled that the party’s decision to replace the former governor with Udenbe violated provisions of the Electoral Act, the 1999 Constitution (as amended), and the APC constitution.
The judgment followed a legal battle instituted by Suswam to challenge the party’s decision to recognise Udenbe as its candidate despite the former governor’s claim that he won the primary election.
In the suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026, Suswam asked the court to recognise him as the rightful winner of the APC primary and its valid candidate for the Benue North East senatorial seat.
He joined the APC, Udenbe and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) as defendants.
During earlier proceedings, INEC’s counsel, Anthony Malik, SAN, told the court that documents submitted by the electoral body showed that Suswam won the party’s primary election.
Malik urged the court to rely on the official result and INEC’s report on the exercise, insisting that the available records established the former governor as the winner.
He consequently asked the court to uphold the primary election result recognising Suswam.
Suswam’s counsel, Jibrin Okutepa, SAN, also urged the court to grant his client’s reliefs, dismissing the preliminary objections filed by the APC and Udenbe as lacking merit.
However, counsel to the APC, A. G. Yirvoms, urged the court to uphold the party’s preliminary objection and dismiss the former governor’s suit.
Suswam had approached the court after the APC handed its Benue North East senatorial ticket to Udenbe, challenging the decision on the grounds that he had won the party’s primary election.



