Ex-appeal court justice urges judges to hold political parties accountable for violating their constitution, Electoral Act

Meanwhile, a SAN said the judiciary must protect electoral integrity without assuming the responsibilities of voters or electoral bodies.

A retired Justice of the Court of Appeal, Oludotun Adefope-Okojie, has urged Nigerian courts to hold political parties accountable when they violate their constitutions or electoral laws, warning that party autonomy should not protect unlawful decisions from judicial scrutiny.

She also cautioned judges against declaring candidates who did not win elections as winners, saying courts should not take over the power of voters to choose their leaders.

Ms Adefope-Okojie spoke on Tuesday in Lagos while delivering the annual lecture of Gavel International, titled Electoral Process in Nigeria: Managing the Boundaries of Judicial Intervention.

“The courts must no longer refuse to intervene where political parties violate their own constitution and ‘rubbish’ the Electoral Act. They must intervene to sanitise the system,” she stated.

The chairman of the event, Anthony George-Ikoli, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), said the judiciary must protect electoral integrity without assuming the responsibilities of voters or electoral bodies.

“The judiciary must neither become an alternative electoral commission nor abdicate its responsibility as the ultimate guardian of electoral legality. That is the delicate boundary we are here this morning to interrogate,” he said.

Mr George-Ikoli said courts must be prepared to address unlawful conduct without exceeding their constitutional responsibilities.

“Judicial restraint should not amount to judicial retreat, just as judicial courage should not degenerate into overreach,” he said.

He added that an election could not be considered credible simply because a winner had emerged, but because the process that produced the winner could withstand legal scrutiny.

Ms Adefope-Okojie stated that the 1,209 petitions filed after Nigeria’s 2023 general elections reflected the level of distrust in the electoral process.

The petitions involved 1,280 elective positions, amounting to about 94.5 petitions for every 100 positions contested. Some seats attracted multiple petitions.

Only 103 of the petitions were successful, she said.

Comparing Nigeria’s experience with other countries, she said Zambia recorded about 83 parliamentary petitions after its 2021 elections for 156 seats, while Malawi had 44 petitions for 193 seats following its 2019 elections.

Kenya recorded 388 petitions involving 1,882 elective positions after its 2017 elections. The figure dropped to 123 after the 2022 elections, representing about 6.5 petitions per 100 seats. Ghana recorded 16 petitions for 275 parliamentary seats after its 2020 elections.

She also cited figures from the United Kingdom, South Africa and the United States. The UK recorded 302 petitions across parliamentary, European and local elections between 1900 and 2016. South Africa received 579 objections to its Electoral Commission after the 2024 elections, while the US recorded 756 election-related cases in 2023 and 2024, most concerning pre-election rules.

She acknowledged that the figures covered different categories of disputes and were not directly comparable.

“These figures do not measure the quality of justice. They measure trust, and on that measure the Nigerian electoral process is in severe deficit,” she said.

Ms Adefope-Okojie pointed to Kenya’s reduction in election petitions as an example of how stronger electoral institutions and effective dispute-resolution mechanisms could ease the burden on courts.

She urged Nigeria to improve the handling of disputes within political parties and at the electoral commission level so that more disagreements could be resolved before they reach election tribunals.

A report by the Policy and Legal Advocacy Centre (PLAC), From Ballot to the Courts: Analysis of Election Petition Litigation from Nigeria’s 2023 General Elections, also examined the outcome of the disputes.

PLAC analysed 1,503 court records, comprising 895 Election Petition Tribunal judgments, 588 Court of Appeal judgments and 20 Supreme Court judgements.

At the tribunal stage, 99 petitions succeeded, while 794 were dismissed. The Court of Appeal allowed 115 appeals and dismissed 446.

PLAC also identified 43 cases in which petitioners won at both the tribunal and appeal stages. Another 42 petitioners lost at the tribunal but succeeded on appeal, while 30 who initially won at the tribunal lost their cases on appeal.

The organisation stated that 4.8 per cent of the tribunal petitions analysed resulted in victories that were sustained through the appeal stage.

It found that the ability of petitioners to establish their cases with credible and admissible evidence determined the outcome of about 73 per cent of the petitions examined. Failure to meet mandatory procedural requirements accounted for 14.7 per cent, lack of jurisdiction for 8.5 per cent and lack of legal standing for 3.7 per cent.

Ms Adefope-Okojie said political parties could not rely on the principle of internal autonomy to justify actions that violated their constitutions or electoral laws.

She cited the Supreme Court’s decision in PDP v Alhaji Sule Lamido, Appeal No. SC/CV/164/2026, delivered on 30 April 2026.

The case followed Mr Lamido’s attempt to obtain a nomination form to contest for the position of national chairman of the Peoples Democratic Party at its 2025 national convention.

In a split 3-2 decision, the Supreme Court held that although courts generally avoid interfering in the internal affairs of political parties, they could intervene where a party violated its constitution or acted contrary to the law.

Justice Stephen Jonah Adah led the majority, alongside Justices Tsammani and Abubakar Sadiq Umar. Two justices dissented.