NGBreakingnews
The file is numbered 24VECV02168, and it sits in Department O of the Van Nuys Courthouse East of the Los Angeles County Superior Court, before Judge Michael R. Amerian. It runs to 195 documents and 82 proceedings. It is the wrongful death case brought over the deaths of Herbert Onyewumbu Wigwe, his wife Doreen Chizoba Wigwe and his son Chizi Wigwe, and until now no report in Nigeria or the United States has described what is inside it. NGBreakingnews has obtained the complaints, the cross-complaints and the court’s orders from that file and its companion case, and what they hold is entirely different from the one version of this lawsuit that was ever published. The helicopter, a Eurocopter EC130B4 on an on-demand charter from Palm Springs to Boulder City, crashed near Halloran Springs in San Bernardino County on the night of 9 February 2024, killing all six people aboard: the three Wigwes, Abimbola Ogunbanjo, and the two pilots, Benjamin Pettingill and Blake Hansen.
The Airbus Lawsuit That Never Existed
The only published account of the family’s American litigation, carried by Ivory NG on 5 February 2025, reported that the Wigwe family had sued Airbus Helicopters. No such case exists. No Airbus company is a defendant in any Wigwe action in any court record, state or federal. The judgment money that account braided into the story, $75 million against Airbus Helicopters and $24.6 million against the operator Papillon Airways, belongs to a different crash and a different family: the 2018 Grand Canyon EC130 crash litigated by the Udall family in Nevada. The Nigerian lawyer that account placed inside the California case, Paul Usoro SAN, appears in no California record; his documented work for the family is the Lagos estate suit, ID/7735FPM/2024. The real defendants in California were the operator of the crashed helicopter and the man who ran it.
Two Lawsuits, One Family, Merged Into One File
The lead action was filed on 8 May 2024. Its six plaintiffs are Otutochi Channel Wigwe, suing individually and as Co-Successor in Interest to Herbert Onyewumbu Wigwe, Doreen Chizoba Wigwe and Chizi Herbert Wigwe; David Chituru Wigwe, a minor; Okachi Great Herbert-Wigwe, a minor; Wegu Hannah Herbert-Wigwe, a minor, the three minors suing by their guardian ad litem, Uchechukwu N. Wigwe; and Shyngle Wigwe and Stella Wigwe, Herbert Wigwe’s father and mother. The defendants are Orbic Air LLC, the Burbank based charter operator, and Brady Bowers, its chief executive, sued personally. On 2 December 2024, Shyngle Wigwe and Stella Wigwe filed a second action of their own, case 24VECV05994, through counsel Christine Diane Spagnoli, against the same two defendants. On 10 March 2025, on the defendants’ own motion, the court consolidated the parents’ case into the lead case and designated 24VECV02168 as the file under which the whole family’s claims would travel. The family’s lead trial counsel is Lane R. Jubb Jr. of The Beasley Firm of Philadelphia.
The parents’ complaint, in hand in full, pleads a case built on total dependence. Shyngle Wigwe is stated to be 90 years old, retired from the civil service over thirty years before; Stella Wigwe is stated to be approaching 85, a stay-at-home mother for most of her life. Both plead that they were financially dependent on their son for the necessaries of life: Herbert provided their housing, monthly monetary contributions for food, a staff to drive, clean and cook, and paid for all their medical care, and they claim standing on that dependence under section 377.60(b) of the California Code of Civil Procedure. Their counsel of record is Christine Diane Spagnoli of Greene Broillet & Wheeler, LLP of El Segundo, acting with Slack Davis Sanger, L.L.P., the Texas aviation firm of Michael L. Slack, Derek Quick and Ladd C. Sanger.
The parents plead two causes of action, both in negligence. The first runs against Orbic Air: as a common carrier it owed its passengers the highest care and the vigilance of a very cautious person, and it is vicariously liable for the piloting of Benjamin Pettingill and Blake Hansen. The second runs against Bowers personally, and it pleads the chief executive as wholly or partially responsible for the safe and reasonable operation of the helicopter, for the supervision of the individuals piloting it, for the oversight and implementation of the company’s policies on flight restrictions due to weather, for ensuring the safety of every passenger, and for the setting of pilot requirements and qualifications; it pleads further that Bowers, an experienced pilot himself, carried his own responsibility for the flight plans of Orbic Air flights he coordinated, scheduled and planned, including the accident flight. The complaint also carries the survival claim in terms: that Herbert Wigwe experienced tremendous fear of impending certain death, pain and suffering before he died. The parents filed a notice of non-opposition to the consolidation of their action into their children’s case.
The Blame Orbic Carried Into Court
Orbic Air and Bowers answered by pointing at South Africa, but not at anyone who maintained the helicopter. On 9 December 2024 they cross-complained in the lead case, and on 31 January 2025 they filed a materially identical cross-complaint in the parents’ case, through Cunningham Swaim LLP, against a cross-defendant whose name the court party index records in full: Continued Airworthiness Maintenance Organisation – South Africa, shortened in later filings to CAMO-SA. For all that its name speaks of maintenance, the cross-complaints do not accuse CAMO-SA of maintaining anything. They plead it as the booking agent for the fatal flight: one or more of the passengers booked the flight through CAMO-SA, which acted by its chief executive, Shane Hayward, as the passengers’ agent.
The cross-complaints plead a written contract at the centre of the manoeuvre. Hayward, they allege, signed a written charter contract with Orbic Air before the flight, containing the charter terms and conditions. The contract, on Orbic’s pleading, specified that CAMO-SA would be liable and fully responsible for any delayed departure; it specified that Orbic Air should not be liable for injury, damage, loss or expense caused by the defect of any vehicle, by delay, flight schedule change, cancellation, sickness, weather or any similar cause; and it recorded that CAMO-SA, Hayward and the passengers acknowledged and assumed the risks inherent in the flight, up to and including personal injury and death. The same contract carried the clause by which a South African company was held answerable in California: any claim, it said, shall be adjudicated in and governed by the laws of the state of California.
On that contract Orbic built a theory of the crash itself. The flight, the cross-complaints allege, was originally planned to depart earlier than 8:45 p.m., but one of the passengers arrived without a passport, which delayed the departure by at least 50 minutes. The weather just prior to the original departure time, they allege, reflected visual flight conditions, and the 50-minute delay caused the aircraft to encounter the poor weather it met. CAMO-SA, the pleading continues, owed the passengers and Orbic the care of an ordinarily careful and prudent helicopter flight booking agent, and breached it by failing to reasonably supervise, monitor, facilitate and coordinate the flight in a safe manner, and by failing to communicate to the passengers the steps necessary for a timely departure; as a direct and proximate result of that negligence, the flight crashed. The five causes of action were indemnification, contractual indemnification, implied contractual indemnification, apportionment of fault and declaratory relief, and the prayer was for total and complete indemnity against any judgment, a proportionate share of any liability, the costs of the suit and Orbic’s attorney fees in defending the family’s action.
CAMO-SA first tried to leave the case altogether, and failed: on 11 August 2025 the court denied its motion to quash service for lack of personal jurisdiction. The cross-complaint was then dismantled in stages. On 6 November 2025 the court sustained CAMO-SA’s demurrer to the contractual indemnity cause of action, with leave to amend. Orbic and Bowers filed a First Amended Cross-Complaint on 17 November 2025, cut down to four causes of action. On 12 March 2026 the court sustained the demurrer again, in part without leave to amend. On 30 March 2026 Orbic and Bowers filed a Second Amended Cross-Complaint, pleading indemnification, a new cause of action for breach of contract, and declaratory relief. CAMO-SA demurred to the whole of it on 1 May 2026.
The end came on 13 July 2026, in an eleven-page order of Judge Amerian sustaining the demurrer to the Second Amended Cross-Complaint without leave to amend and dismissing that cross-complaint with prejudice. The order sets out the Responsibility clause of the charter contract in full, and the words are a shield written for Orbic Air alone: Orbic Air, LLC shall not be liable for any injury, damage, loss, expense, indirect, special or consequential damages, or other irregularity caused by the defect of any vehicle or conveyance, or the negligence of any company or person engaged in conveying the passenger or carrying out the arrangements for the trip, or by accident, delay, flight schedule, change, cancellation, sickness, weather, strikes, war, quarantine, or any similar cause, and company liability shall in any case be limited to the amount paid to Orbic Air. Nowhere in the clause does CAMO-SA promise to answer for a late departure. The court held that the provision only contains language creating a shield for Orbic’s benefit against liability, as opposed to a sword it can use to create a duty in anyone else; that a booking agent exercises no control over flight conditions, weather or the decision to fly; that a logistical planner is in no way tasked with responsibility for flight safety; and that foreseeability built on punctuality cannot stand against the public policy favouring aeronautical safety over all other factors. The new breach of contract cause of action fell with the rest: it had been added without the leave the court’s earlier order required, and it rested on the same duty the court held the contract does not create. Declaratory relief, predicated on the two dead causes of action, fell last.
What Is Still Alive In Van Nuys
The lead case remains open on the court’s register, its status E-Filed. The cross-complaint Orbic Air built against the South African firm stands dismissed with prejudice. What survives is the argument over the cost of that failed manoeuvre: CAMO-SA moved on 28 August 2026 for $353,860.50 in attorney fees against the operator and its chief executive, and Orbic and Bowers moved on 20 August 2026 to tax costs. The fees fight has been heard and continued through the autumn, and it stands next on 8 December 2026 in Department 511, with a final status conference set for 19 February 2027 and a jury trial date of 1 March 2027.
Follow NGBreakingnews on WhatsApp: join the channel for every exclusive the moment it publishes.


