“Eight-Year Service Commitment Must Be Fulfilled” — Court Upholds Navy’s Refusal Of Officer’s Resignation, Awards ₦2m Costs

The President of the National Industrial Court of Nigeria, Justice Benedict Kanyip, OFR, has dismissed a suit filed by a Nigerian Navy officer, Anthony, challenging the refusal of the Chief of Naval Staff and the Nigerian Navy to approve his voluntary resignation before the expiration of his mandatory eight-year service commitment.

Justice Kanyip held that officers commissioned into the Nigerian Navy under the Direct Short Service Commission (DSSC) scheme are bound by the terms and conditions governing their enlistment, including the requirement to complete an initial eight-year period of service before seeking voluntary resignation.

The Court also ruled that the refusal of the naval authorities to approve Anthony’s resignation before the expiration of his initial engagement did not violate Section 306 of the 1999 Constitution, as amended, or amount to forced or compulsory labour under Section 34 of the Constitution and applicable International Labour Organization (ILO) Conventions.

In addition, the Court held that the claimant’s action was statute-barred under the Public Officers Protection Act, having been instituted after the applicable limitation period.

The Court consequently dismissed the suit and awarded ₦2 million in costs against Anthony in favour of the Chief of Naval Staff and the Nigerian Navy, payable within 30 days.

The dispute arose from Anthony’s attempt to leave the Nigerian Navy approximately five years after his commissioning under the Direct Short Service Commission scheme.

According to the facts presented before the Court, Anthony was commissioned into the Nigerian Navy in March 2015 under Direct Short Service Commission Course 22 as a Surgeon Sub-Lieutenant.

He subsequently submitted an application for voluntary resignation through a letter dated September 28, 2020, which he maintained was received and acknowledged by the Chief of Naval Staff.

Anthony stated that following the failure of the naval authorities to approve his application, he submitted another letter dated February 18, 2021, reiterating his intention to resign from the service.

The second letter, according to him, was acknowledged by the defendants on February 25, 2021.

Dissatisfied with the refusal to approve his resignation, Anthony approached the National Industrial Court, seeking declarations that he possessed a constitutional right to voluntarily disengage from the Nigerian Navy.

He also urged the Court to declare that his resignation letter dated September 28, 2020, was valid and effective.

His counsel relied on Section 306 of the 1999 Constitution, as amended, arguing that the provision guaranteed public officers the right to resign from office upon the receipt of their resignation letters by the appropriate authorities.

Counsel contended that the constitutional right to resign could not be subjected to the approval or discretion of the defendants.

The claimant further argued that the refusal of the naval authorities to allow him to leave the service constituted forced labour and infringed his constitutional rights, as well as protections under relevant International Labour Organization Conventions.

However, the Chief of Naval Staff and the Nigerian Navy opposed the suit, maintaining that Anthony had voluntarily accepted the conditions attached to his commissioning.

The defendants explained that the claimant was enlisted under the Direct Short Service Commission scheme and was consequently subject to the Harmonised Terms and Conditions of Service for Officers, 2017 (Revised).

According to the defendants, the applicable conditions of service prescribed a minimum initial engagement period of eight years for officers commissioned under the scheme.

They maintained that Anthony had served for approximately five years when he applied to resign in September 2020 and had therefore not fulfilled his mandatory service obligation.

The naval authorities further disclosed that his application was expressly declined through a letter dated November 2, 2020, on the ground that he had not completed the required eight-year service period.

Counsel to the defendants, Al-Ameen Abubakar, Esq., argued that members of the Armed Forces were not entitled to resign at will without regard to the laws, regulations and contractual conditions governing their service.

He submitted that military service was subject to specific obligations and disciplinary requirements which distinguished it from ordinary civilian employment.

Abubakar consequently urged the Court to dismiss the claimant’s action.

In determining the suit, Justice Kanyip first considered whether the action was competent in view of the limitation provisions of the Public Officers Protection Act.

The Court held that Anthony had failed to pursue his claim within the legally prescribed period and had allowed more than five years to elapse before instituting the action.

Justice Kanyip consequently found that the suit was statute-barred.

The Court nevertheless proceeded to examine the substantive constitutional and employment issues raised by the parties.

In resolving those issues, Justice Kanyip considered Sections 1, 34, 217, 254C and 306 of the 1999 Constitution, alongside ILO Conventions Nos. 29 and 105 concerning forced labour.

The Court held that the constitutional provisions dealing with resignation, the prohibition of forced labour and the organisation and responsibilities of the Armed Forces must be interpreted harmoniously rather than in isolation.

Justice Kanyip acknowledged that the Constitution did not expressly exclude military personnel from its application.

However, he held that the right to resign must be considered within the broader constitutional, statutory and international legal framework regulating military service.

According to the Court, Anthony voluntarily joined the Nigerian Navy under a scheme that required him to complete an initial eight-year period of engagement.

Having accepted those conditions, the claimant was bound by the applicable terms of service and could not insist on leaving before completing the agreed period without complying with the governing requirements.

Justice Kanyip held that the Chief of Naval Staff and the Nigerian Navy were entitled to enforce the minimum service requirement and decline an application for voluntary resignation submitted prematurely.

The Court therefore rejected the argument that the defendants’ refusal to approve the claimant’s resignation violated Section 306 of the Constitution.

On the allegation of forced labour, Justice Kanyip held that enforcing the initial period of military service voluntarily undertaken by Anthony did not amount to forced or compulsory labour within the meaning of Section 34 of the Constitution or ILO Conventions Nos. 29 and 105.

The Court reasoned that the claimant was not being compelled to remain in military service indefinitely or beyond the initial engagement period stipulated in the terms he had accepted.

Rather, the naval authorities had informed him that he could submit another application for voluntary resignation upon completing the mandatory eight years.

Consequently, the Court found no basis for concluding that the enforcement of the agreed initial service period constituted an infringement of the claimant’s constitutional rights.

Justice Kanyip maintained that the rights and obligations arising from military service must be considered together, particularly where an officer voluntarily accepts specific conditions upon enlistment.

The Court accordingly upheld the Nigerian Navy’s position that officers commissioned under the Direct Short Service Commission scheme must comply with the prescribed minimum engagement period before seeking voluntary resignation.

Having found the action statute-barred and the claimant’s substantive arguments without merit, Justice Kanyip dismissed the suit.

The Court further ordered Anthony to pay ₦2 million in costs to the defendants within 30 days.

The post “Eight-Year Service Commitment Must Be Fulfilled” — Court Upholds Navy’s Refusal Of Officer’s Resignation, Awards ₦2m Costs appeared first on TheNigeriaLawyer.