Jagaban Scorecard Series: Banwo Gives Tinubu 4/10 on Jobs, Faults Employment Figures

Banwo gave the rating in the third episode of his Jagaban Scorecard Series (JSS), which examines the administration’s performance on employment. In an earlier episode of the series, he also scored Tinubu 4 out of 10 on security.

In his latest assessment, Banwo questioned whether reported economic growth was translating into meaningful employment opportunities, pointing to the closure of businesses and intense competition for available vacancies.

He also challenged the reliability of headline unemployment figures, arguing that the method of measuring employment could fail to capture the extent of underemployment and the poor quality of jobs available to many Nigerians.

According to him, counting people who work for as little as one hour in a week as employed does not adequately reflect whether they earn enough to support themselves or have access to sustainable work.

Banwo illustrated his argument with examples of university graduates who remain financially dependent on their parents years after graduation, as well as others who take up jobs outside their areas of training, including commercial driving and informal trading.

He said many Nigerians engaged in petty trading, commercial motorcycle operations and point-of-sale businesses might be classified as employed, even when their activities generate insufficient or unstable incomes.

The analyst further argued that the number of people entering the labour market annually far exceeds the supply of formal jobs.

He cited estimates of between 500,000 and 600,000 graduates entering the labour market each year, while putting the total number of annual entrants, including non-graduates, at about 1.8 million.

Against this, he estimated that the formal economy creates between 400,000 and 500,000 jobs annually, leaving a substantial number of job seekers to depend on informal activities.

Banwo attributed the limited capacity of businesses to recruit more workers partly to high operating costs, including unreliable electricity supply, expensive borrowing, rising fuel expenses and multiple tax demands.

He argued that these pressures make business expansion difficult and limit the ability of employers to create additional jobs. Rather than attempting to provide all jobs directly, he said, government should focus on creating conditions that allow businesses to grow and employ more people.

He also identified the continued desire among Nigerians to relocate abroad as a reflection of concerns about employment prospects and economic opportunities at home.

While acknowledging that some businesses were still recruiting, Banwo maintained that the availability of work did not necessarily translate into financial security, particularly as inflation continued to erode workers’ purchasing power.

He said the country’s employment challenge was therefore not simply the number of people without jobs, but the shortage of decent work capable of providing stable incomes and improving living standards.

On that basis, he awarded Tinubu 4 out of 10 on the jobs and employment index, adding that Nigerians would ultimately determine how the administration’s performance should be judged.