An unusual legal battle is unfolding in South Africa concerning the mental well-being of three elephants housed in a zoo.
Animal welfare groups say the three animals are depressed and are advocating for their relocation to a larger conservation park where they can be happy.
The case, set to be heard this week, will decide if the state is meeting its legal obligations regarding the welfare of the animals and the conditions in which they are kept, according to David Bilchitz, a board member at Animal Law Reform South Africa, one of the groups bringing the case.
Bilchitz said experts would present evidence in court that the elephants are unhappy.
The animal welfare groups said a part of the South African Constitution puts an obligation on authorities to look after animals.
The zoo in question in Johannesburg is publicly owned and has defended its management of the elephants, saying they are well cared for.
Bilchitz said elephants have highly complex social structures and specific physical and mental needs, and generally live in herds of 20 to 50 animals that roam large areas in the wild.
He said that the three elephants at the zoo, named Lammie, Ramadiba and Mopane, live in an enclosure not much bigger than a soccer field with none of the typical stimulation that elephants need, like trees to forage from and mud pools to bathe in.
“They are sad, depressed and frustrated,” Bilchitz said. “They are listless and stand around.” He said the elephants had shown signs of psychological distress, like standing and rocking and other “repetitive compulsive behaviour.”
Johannesburg Zoo said in a statement that there had been a “media scourge” over the condition of the elephants and maintained they were healthy and also popular with zoo staff and visitors. It also said that relocating elephants from zoos to semiwild sanctuaries is not always successful.
There is a kind of precedent for the case. In 2024, an old bull elephant called Charley was relocated from another South African zoo to a game reserve after he outlived his elephant companions at the zoo and animal experts believed he was lonely.
The zoo agreed that Charley should be taken to the reserve to retire after he spent decades in captivity, including around 16 years in a circus.
