*Laments Pressure From Nigerians Over Bid To Set Aside Subpoena For Tinubu’s Records
Proceedings in the criminal trial of human rights activist and African Action Congress (AAC) presidential candidate, Omoyele Sowore, at the Federal High Court in Abuja on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, took an unusual turn when counsel to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Alex Izinyon, SAN, complained about mounting public pressure over his involvement in the case and raised concerns about the presiding judge’s late commencement of court proceedings.
The presiding judge, Justice Mohammed Garba Umar, also disclosed that he had been under pressure following public reactions to his recent illness, which prevented him from sitting at a scheduled hearing.
The exchanges occurred during proceedings concerning a subpoena issued against the INEC Chairman, Professor Joash Ojo Amupitan, SAN, directing the electoral commission to produce documents relating to President Bola Ahmed Tinubu’s electoral records.
According to SaharaReporters, Izinyon told the court that his experience since accepting the brief to challenge the subpoena had been unpleasant, as he had received numerous telephone calls and messages from Nigerians questioning his involvement in the matter.
The senior advocate also complained about conditions in the courtroom and what he described as Justice Umar’s habitual lateness, suggesting changes to the court’s daily schedule to reduce delays experienced by lawyers and litigants.
The dispute arose in Sowore’s ongoing criminal trial over his public description of President Tinubu as a criminal.
As part of his defence, Sowore is seeking the production of documents relating to Tinubu’s 1999 governorship candidacy in Lagos State and his 2023 presidential candidacy.
Justice Umar had issued a subpoena duces tecum directing the INEC Chairman to produce the documents before the court.
However, INEC, represented by Izinyon, filed an application seeking to set aside the subpoena, while Sowore’s legal team maintained that the requested documents should be produced.
The matter also became complicated by applications filed by the defence to regularise aspects of the subpoena and correct errors identified in the process.
During Tuesday’s proceedings, Sowore’s lawyer, Ralph Adakole, who appeared on behalf of lead defence counsel Adeyinka Olumide-Fusika, SAN, informed the court that the defence would not need to withdraw the existing subpoena.
His submission followed a suggestion by Justice Umar that the defence should put INEC on notice of its proposed amendment to the subpoena.
In addressing the court, Adakole described Izinyon as a revered senior lawyer, a compliment that prompted the senior advocate to respond.
Izinyon acknowledged the remarks but disclosed that his experience since accepting INEC’s brief had been “anything but pleasant”.
According to the report, he explained that the situation changed after he filed the application seeking to set aside the subpoena compelling the electoral commission to produce Tinubu’s records.
He told the judge that he had been receiving numerous telephone calls and messages from Nigerians, many of whom he believed were sympathetic to Sowore.
The senior advocate said some of the callers and message senders warned him against compromising the case.
He explained that while some of the messages were respectful and moderate, others were considerably less pleasant.
Izinyon lamented that the attention surrounding his involvement in the trial had become overwhelming, despite the fact that he was acting in his professional capacity as a legal practitioner representing a client.
He consequently appealed to Justice Umar to help persuade Nigerians to “take it easy” with him.
The senior advocate maintained that his appearance in the proceedings was part of his professional responsibility to represent INEC and its chairman in the dispute over the subpoena.
Beyond the public reactions to his involvement, Izinyon raised concerns about the conditions under which proceedings were being conducted.
According to SaharaReporters, the lawyer complained about the stuffy atmosphere in the courtroom before drawing attention to what he described as the judge’s repeated late arrival.
He told the court that Justice Umar was known to commence proceedings at approximately 10:30 a.m., despite the scheduled starting time of 9:00 a.m.
Izinyon explained that his observations were not intended to embarrass the judge but to highlight the difficulties the late commencement of proceedings created for lawyers, litigants and the administration of justice.
He argued that repeated delays affected the ability of counsel to plan their court appearances and attend to other professional engagements.
The senior advocate suggested that if the judge was unable to commence proceedings consistently at 9:00 a.m., the court should consider reorganising its daily cause list to reflect the time proceedings ordinarily began.
Under his proposal, the first six cases on the cause list could be scheduled between 10:30 a.m. and noon, with subsequent matters arranged for the remaining hours before the court rose for the day.
Izinyon maintained that such an arrangement would enable lawyers and litigants to plan their appearances more effectively rather than spending several hours waiting for proceedings to commence.
He argued that a more realistic schedule would reduce uncertainty and improve the management of cases before the court.
According to the report, Justice Umar appeared unsettled by the observations but nodded and indicated that he would consider the suggestions.
The judge then responded to the senior advocate’s complaints about the pressure he had experienced since taking INEC’s brief.
Rather than addressing the lawyer’s concerns directly, Justice Umar disclosed that he had also been subjected to considerable public pressure over the proceedings.
The judge referred to media reports and public commentary concerning his recent illness, which had prevented him from sitting during a scheduled hearing the previous week.
He expressed frustration that his inability to preside over the case because of ill health had generated public scrutiny and criticism.
Justice Umar questioned whether a judge was no longer entitled to fall sick without attracting adverse public reactions.
According to SaharaReporters, the judge’s response brought the exchange to an abrupt end.
Izinyon subsequently took his seat and requested that the court call the next case.
Justice Umar thereafter adjourned Sowore’s trial until Monday, November 23, 2026.
The unusual exchanges followed an earlier disagreement between the defence and counsel to the INEC Chairman over the proper procedure for amending or regularising the subpoena.
During the previous proceedings, Izinyon announced his appearance for Professor Amupitan, who had been subpoenaed in connection with the trial.
He informed the court that his client had a pending application seeking to set aside the subpoena issued to compel his participation and the production of the requested electoral documents.
However, Adakole informed the court that Sowore had filed an ex parte application seeking to regularise service of the subpoena on the INEC Chairman.
The defence lawyer also disclosed that on November 11, 2026, Sowore had applied for leave to regularise his position concerning the challenge to the subpoena and to amend the process.
The applications raised questions about whether the existing subpoena should remain in place while the defence pursued corrections or whether it should first be withdrawn.
Izinyon opposed the procedure adopted by the defence, arguing that because the subpoena had already been issued and served, any attempt to amend or regularise it should be made by a motion on notice to the parties concerned.
He maintained that a subpoena constituted a formal command issued by the court and could not simply be amended without complying with the appropriate legal procedure.
The senior advocate further argued that the defence could not simultaneously challenge the existing process and seek to regularise it without first addressing the pending application seeking to set it aside.
He therefore urged the court to direct Sowore’s legal team to withdraw the original subpoena and correct any procedural defects before proceeding.
However, Adakole disagreed, maintaining that both applications could remain pending before the court.
He explained that Sowore was still within the period permitted by law to respond to the application filed on behalf of the INEC Chairman.
According to the defence counsel, the separate application seeking to regularise the subpoena would not prejudice the opposing party if allowed to remain before the court.
He argued that maintaining both applications would preserve the defendant’s procedural options, including the possibility of withdrawing the regularisation application if it subsequently became unnecessary.
Adakole consequently urged the court not to compel the defence to withdraw the subpoena merely because it was seeking to correct certain aspects of the process.
Following the arguments, the court indicated that the defence could proceed with its application, while the opposing party retained the right to raise objections at the appropriate stage.
The disagreement over the subpoena remains central to the proceedings because the defence is seeking electoral records relating to Tinubu’s governorship and presidential candidacies.
INEC’s application to set aside the subpoena, on the other hand, challenges the requirement that the Commission produce the requested documents.
The court has yet to conclusively determine the competing applications based on the proceedings described.
The controversy has attracted considerable public attention because of the nature of Sowore’s prosecution and the involvement of INEC in the dispute concerning the production of the President’s electoral records.
The latest proceedings have also drawn attention to the experiences of lawyers involved in politically sensitive cases, the public scrutiny of judicial officers and concerns about the timely commencement of court sittings.
Izinyon’s complaints centred on the pressure he said he had received from members of the public over his professional representation of INEC, as well as the effect of delayed court sittings on lawyers and litigants.
Justice Umar, meanwhile, expressed concern over the public reactions to his illness and the criticism surrounding his absence from a previous hearing.
With the matter adjourned until November 23, 2026, the court is expected to continue addressing the procedural applications concerning the subpoena issued to the INEC Chairman.
The post “10:30am Instead Of 9am” — INEC Lawyer Izinyon Confronts Judge Over Habitual Lateness To Court During Sowore’s Trial appeared first on TheNigeriaLawyer.

